I wasn’t really expecting to find a lot of Karl Barth or P.T. Forsyth, but there wasn’t even any C. S. Lewis, Madeleine L’Engle, Philip Yancey, Tony Campolo, Eugene Peterson, or John Stott, card-carrying evangelicals all.
And it dawned on me that certain Christians live in a parallel intellectual universe to the one I live in. These were “Christian” books, and it got me to ruminating on whether the whole idea of a Christian book is a good one.
Remember the old joke that said: “Military justice is to justice what military music is to music.” Is it possible that “Christian books are to books what military music is to music?” I admit that I am a literary snob, and a theological one, too, but isn't there some standard of aesthetics that faithfulness requires of our art and literature, even if we disagree on just what that standard is?
I once got into an argument about music in church in which I argued that Christian worship demands good music, and my interlocutor said there is no such thing as bad or good music, just personal preference. I couldn’t disagree more. And it is not like I am wedded to one kind of music. I enjoy lots of kinds of music, but it has to be good music. Likewise I like all kinds of literature, but it has to be good.
I know I will probably get hate mail for saying this, but I didn’t like the Jan Karon “Mitford Series” because it seemed too preachy and contrived. My beloved Aunt Tia (now deceased so I can say this) was always pushing these books at me because they were “so Christian.” “You’ll like them,” she said, “because they describe a clergyman and his life with his congregation.” I guess it never occurred to her that being a pastor for thirty years I may have known all that I wanted to know about a clergyman and his congregation. And the clergyman in these books, while charming, seemed too good to be true, which is a bad thing in art and literature which demands, above all, truthfulness.
So I wonder if there can be such a thing as a Christian writer? There are writers who are Christian, and even deal in Christian themes, but I read them because they are good writers. I am thinking of Annie Dillard, Marilyne Robinson, and John Updike, to name but a few. And there are books that have Christian themes like John Irving's A Prayer for Owen Meany and Graham Green's The Power and the Glory, although I have never heard either of the authors described as a Christian writer. Frederick Buechner writes luminous non-fiction devotional and theological books, but his novels, like The Book of Bebb, are never preachy or contrived.
What all these writers share is that they tell a story, and you don't feel like you are reading a religious tract. In their novels the themes of religion are woven into the fabric of life, as religion is itself in our lives; it's not a separate thing.
For example, I never thought of Charlotte Bronte’s Jane Eyre as a “Christian” novel, and yet when George Hunsinger asked our theology class to look for themes of “providence” running through the book it jumped out at me that Bronte, the parson’s daughter, was indeed spinning out a Christian theology. But what makes it worth reading is that it is so well written, just as Marilyne Robinson’s Home may have Christian themes running through it, but it is a book worth reading because it is a good book.
Good literature, like all good art, never descends to propaganda, even for a worthy cause such as Christ and his church. Let us be wary of Christian books.
Good literature, like all good art, never descends to propaganda, even for a worthy cause such as Christ and his church. Let us be wary of Christian books.
I taught a novel class at an evangelical college and was taken to task by several conservative students for assigning The Power and the Glory. Greene isn't a Christian, they claimed, he's a Catholic. After enough encounters of the sort, my wife and I left that college and founded an online writing program at Perelandra College(www.perelandra.edu), our primary goal being to help Christians write good, honest books.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, thanks for your exellent post.
Thanks Ken. I see from your Website that you write in the mystery genre. I'll have to check that out, as I love reading them (again good ones.) You might be interested in a paper I did about my long love affair with the genre called The Butler Did It! on another site: http://mondayeveningclub.blogspot.com/2009/02/butler-did-it-passion-for-mystery.html
ReplyDeleteGreat post. We have a similar bookstore here in the sprawling DC suburbs. But what is surprising here is that they seem to sell far more t-shirts and chotchkies than books. So, I insist on calling it "the Christian Stuffstore." More stuff than books, after all.
ReplyDeleteFlannery O'Conner has written wonderfully on this topic of "Christian art," as I'm sure you know.
Andy,
ReplyDeleteI have read quite a bit of O'Connor, but can't put my finger on what she said about Christian art. But it most likely lurks somewhere in my unconscious. Most of what I think has been thought before me. As Will Willimon once said about preachers, “the worst thing you can be is original.”
Well, to be precise, she writes about Catholic fiction writing in her book _Mystery and Manners_. Several essays in that (wonderful) collection say what you say: that the important thing for a Christian author is to, as you put it, "tell a story, and you don't feel like you are reading a religious tract. In their novels the themes of religion are woven into the fabric of life, as religion is itself in our lives; it's not a separate thing.
ReplyDeleteSpeaking of Willimon, I think I heard a similar quote attributed to Hauerwas. Something along the lines of: "Anyone who thinks they've had an original thought has just forgotten where they've read it."
I once heard Stanley say something to the effect that Willimon never had a thought he didn't publish, and a lot of mine too!
ReplyDeleteBut it goes to prove the point about originality, don't you think?